When you’re craving the best pizza in Pinetop, there’s one name locals always recommend—Red Devil Restaurant. Nestled in the heart of Pinetop, AZ, our family-owned Italian eatery has built a reputation not just for flavor-packed pizza, but also for warm hospitality, fresh ingredients, and—most famously—our signature secret sauces.
Whether you’re a longtime resident or just visiting the White Mountains, you’ve probably asked yourself: Where can I find the best pizza near Pinetop AZ? The answer is right here.
What Makes Red Devil the Best Pizza in Pinetop?
The secret to our success is simple: consistency, quality, and tradition.
At Red Devil, we handcraft our dough daily, use only the freshest toppings, and cook each pizza to perfection in ovens that bring out authentic flavor and crispness. But that’s just the beginning.
Our homemade pizza sauces—a blend of herbs, tomatoes, garlic, and carefully guarded family techniques—are what really make the difference. Every slice is a tribute to old-world Italian craftsmanship with a touch of Arizona heart.
Don’t just take our word for it—ask the locals. Red Devil has been a top-rated pizza spot in Pinetop for years, attracting families, tourists, and foodies from all over the state.
Searching for Pizza Near Pinetop, AZ?
If you’re on your phone right now googling “pizza near Pinetop AZ”, save yourself the time—Red Devil is your go-to spot.
Located at a convenient spot in Pinetop, we’re just minutes away from local resorts, cabins, and trailheads. Whether you’re picking up after a long hike or dining in with friends, our friendly service and cozy atmosphere make for the perfect pizza stop.
Check out our full Pizza Menu Here to browse customer favorites like our Red Devil Combo, BBQ Chicken Pizza, and classic Margherita.
Beyond Pizza—A Full Italian Dining Experience
While we’re known for having the best pizza in Pinetop, that’s just part of the story. Red Devil Restaurant offers a full Italian menu that includes:
- Homemade pastas
- Fresh salads
- Toasty subs
- Garlic knots and wings
- Italian desserts
So, if you’re dining with someone who’s not in the mood for pizza (hey, it happens!), they’ll still find something mouthwatering to enjoy.
We also offer event catering and group dining options—perfect for family get-togethers, birthdays, or post-ski outings. Just let us know what you need!
The Secret Sauces Locals Can’t Get Enough Of
We couldn’t write a blog about why we’re the best without talking about our secret sauces. Our pizza sauces are made fresh every day, using imported Italian tomatoes, garden-fresh herbs, and a blend of seasonings we’ve perfected over decades.
Red sauce or white, traditional or spicy—our customers say it’s what keeps them coming back. And it’s not just on the pizzas. We use our sauces across the menu, from our pasta dishes to our dipping sides, giving every bite that bold, unforgettable flavor.
A Pinetop Pizza Tradition Since Day One
What sets Red Devil apart isn’t just the food—it’s the community. We’re a family-run restaurant that’s proud to be part of the Pinetop story.
Over the years, we’ve seen families grow up with Red Devil, and visitors return summer after summer. It’s not unusual to hear, “This is the first place we stop when we get to town.” That loyalty means everything to us.
So when people say we’re the best pizza in Pinetop, we believe it’s because we treat our guests like family—and serve pizza that tastes like home.
Ready to Taste the Best Pizza in Pinetop?
Whether you’re a Pinetop local or just passing through, make your next meal a slice of something unforgettable. Order online, call ahead, or stop in and enjoy the best pizza in town—made with love, fresh ingredients, and a whole lot of flavor.
Explore our full pizza menu here, and let us know if you want it for pickup, dine-in, or delivery.